Constructing an MLB dynasty requires more than a great team. The sport is laced with natural variables, not to mention the risk of pitching injuries and untimely slumps from key hitters.
Even those who are World Series favourites in baseball betting for over a decade do not necessarily build a dynasty.
The best teams consistently excel in the regular season. Having a team with multiple MLB betting favourites for MVP might guarantee 95+ wins in the regular year, but it doesn’t always equate to playoff success.
Greatest MLB Dynasties Of All Time
-
San Francisco Giants (2011 - 2014)
-
New York Yankees (1996 - 2001)
-
Cincinnati Reds (1970 - 1979)
-
Oakland Athletics (1972 - 1975)
-
New York Yankees (1947 - 1953)
Over the last half-century, winning a World Series has only got tougher. It’s not a case of winning one playoff series. Every team has to win at least three, and the expansion of the wild-card round has created an extra hurdle.
Winning postseason games is small-sample size stuff. There are different challenges, both mentally and physically, with the intensity of postseason play.
Some of these all-time great MLB dynasties existed when the perils of the postseason were much less, when being the best team in your league propelled you straight to the World Series.
Others had to navigate round after round, seeing off red-hot opponents and maintaining momentum.
San Francisco Giants (2011-14)
Never a baseball betting favourite, the San Francisco Giants were underdogs for much of their early 2010s dynasty. Bruce Bochy navigated his team to three titles in five years, carried by even-year magic.
The Giants were an unusual dynasty. They missed the playoffs in 2011 and 2013, and they averaged just over 91 wins in their title years.
Division winners in 2010 and 1212, San Francisco needed a wildcard win in 2014, which they got on the back of a complete game shutout from Madison Bumgarner.
Bumgarner was a post-season hero throughout, pitching brilliantly as a rookie in 2010, repeating it in 2012 and putting the team on his back in 2014. His five-inning Game 7 outing against the Royals was the stuff of legend.
Much of this was about the bullpen. Bochy, a future Hall of Fame manager, guided his team through each playoff run, managing his relief group supremely. They had a bullpen ERA below 2.50 in those three postseasons.
San Francisco had a knack for big performances beyond Bumgarner. Marco Scutaro, Pablo Sandoval, Hunter Pence, Cody Ross, Tim Lincecum, and Buster Posey all had their magic moments.
Those three titles elevated the Giants to fifth all-time in World Series wins, which was two ahead of their rival Los Angeles Dodgers. The Dodgers have since joined the Giants on eight.
New York Yankees (1996-2001)
The Yankees, like the Giants, had it harder than teams from decades past.
They had to win more games to get to the promised land, and that makes it all the more remarkable that the Yanks won four World Series in five years. Their 1998-2000 threepeat was the first since Oakland’s in 1974.
These Yankees teams had great depth beyond the star names of Roger Clemens, Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada, and Mariano Rivera.
It was a combination of hefty ownership spending and superb player development that built an unstoppable force in the Big Apple.
A deep rotation, the greatest relief pitcher ever and a stacked line-up made the Yankees as close to unbeatable as any team has been in recent playoff history.
We are still waiting for a franchise to replicate the Yankees' dominance -- no team has come close since.
Cincinnati Reds (1970-79)
Where other dynastic teams are often built on aces and, in the modern era, lockdown bullpens, the Cincinnati Reds were all about the offence. They had a line-up as good as any in Major League history.
The Big Red Machine had four players who combined for six MVPs during the 1970s.
They won six division titles, took home four National League pennants and twice won it all, beating the Red Sox in seven games in 1975 and sweeping the Yankees a year later.
Johnny Bench, Joe Morgan, Pete Rose and George Foster shared the aforementioned MVPs, but they were not alone.
Tony Perez averaged 27 homers per season from 1969 through to 1976. Ken Griffey Sr. was a multiple-time All-Star. Davey Concepcion and Cesar Geronimo were Gold Glove winners.
Reds fans have been waiting a long time for team anything like the Big Red Machine again. Cincy has made only five postseason appearances since winning the Fall Classic in 1990.
Oakland Athletics (1972-75)
Although the franchise is better known for its underdog status, a controversial move away from the Bay Area, and the film Moneyball these days, the Oakland Athletics were loaded with big names and stars in the 1970s.
They were a team of entertainers, a trend that extended all the way to owner Charles O. Finley. Oakland won their division five years in a row in the early 70s, but it was the middle three years that were the triumphant ones.
The A’s took three World Series on the bounce, beating the Reds in 1972, Mets in 1973 and Dodgers in 1974. It could have been even more successful, however, as they fell in the ALCS in 1975 and 1971.
Reggie Jackson, who became known as Mr October, won his first World Series MVP in the win over the Mets. Catfish Hunter won 20 or more games in four straight years over this run.
Hall of Famer and moustache icon Rollie Fingers was as dominant as they come out of the bullpen, notching eight saves and a 1.55 ERA over their three titles runs.
They had power, speed, elite pitching and more than their fair share of personality.
Oakland has only won the Fall Classic once since those great 70s teams, but what a time it was to be an A’s fan.
New York Yankees (1947-1953)
Picking a second Yankees team for this article was an impossible challenge. Such was their dominance from the 1940s through the 1960s, any year range could be selected and have a solid argument made for it.
We tried to keep the window small, though, and went for the all-conquering 1947 to 1953 era.
New York won six World Series in seven years, a barely fathomable achievement. The Brooklyn Dodgers were on the receiving end, losing four of those six series.
That rivalry has remained through to the modern day, even with the Dodgers located on the other side of the country. It was reignited in the 2024 Fall Classic, with the Dodgers winning in five games.
These teams were led by the star power of a late-career Joe DiMaggio and a young Yogi Berra, with Mickey Mantle exploding onto the scene towards the end of the run – Mantle went on to win seven World Series.
Johnny Mize, Phil Rizzuto, Billy Martin and Bobby Brown all starred, too, as the Yanks made history. It’s a run that has never been repeated, and likely never will be.
MLB Dynasties FAQs
What Is An MLB Dynasty?
An MLB dynasty is when a team dominates the sport for an extended period.
Three titles in six or seven years should be viewed as the minimum criteria for a dynasty in baseball.
What Qualifies A Team As A Dynasty?
A team qualifies as a dynasty by putting together a sustained period of dominant performances.
Postseason success is a must to be considered as a dynasty in MLB – multiple titles in a five-year period is a good benchmark.
What Is The Greatest Dynasty In MLB History?
The 1996-2001 New York Yankees are the greatest dynasty in MLB history.
Five World Series appearances and four titles in six years is an unmatched achievement in the modern era.
The standard across the majors was much higher than dynasties from past eras, and they had more significant postseason challenges due to the extra rounds.
What Is The Longest MLB Dynasty?
It depends how you define a dynasty. The Yankees winning 10 titles in a 16-year span between 1947 and 1962 could easily be grouped as one dynasty, which would make the longest dynasty in baseball history.
Is Three Titles In Five Years A Dynasty?
Yes, three titles in a five-year span should be viewed as a dynasty.
This is a very rare achievement in any sport, and especially so with the length of the MLB postseason in the 21st century.
*Credit for the photos in this article belongs to Alamy*
